Summary dismissal for misleading the company doctor: what did the Amsterdam court decide?

Empty wheelchair with an arm sling next to the counter of a fast-food restaurant

On 13 November 2026, the subdistrict court in Amsterdam upheld the summary dismissal (ontslag op staande voet) of an employee who had presented himself to the company doctor (bedrijfsarts) as more limited than he really was (ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2026:11330). He arrived at the appointment in a wheelchair with his arm in a sling. Shortly afterwards, he got out of the wheelchair, walked briskly behind it and lifted a bag.

The court did not doubt that the employee was ill. What mattered was the picture he had given the company doctor. The ruling also shows that an employer may take time for a careful investigation without the dismissal coming too late.

What happened?

The employee had worked at a McDonald’s restaurant since 7 April 2015. His employer was MacBlauwFacility B.V. He was on sick leave, and according to the company doctor he had serious limitations in static and dynamic activities and in travel. As a result, he was said to be unable to take part in any return-to-work activity.

In May 2026, the management received signals that the employee was less limited than he claimed. The employer then had a corporate investigation service look into it. During an observation on 29 June 2026, the investigators saw that after an appointment with the company doctor, the employee got out of the wheelchair, kept walking behind it, removed the bandage from his arm and lifted a bag. There was also video footage.

Timeline

DateEvent
7 April 2015Employee starts work
May 2026Management receives signals that the employee is less limited
26 May 2026Meeting with the employee about his illness
June 2026Investigation by the corporate investigation service
29 June 2026Observation after an appointment with the company doctor
2 July 2026Meeting and summary dismissal
13 November 2026Oral judgment of the Amsterdam subdistrict court

Why was there an urgent reason?

Under Dutch law, an employer may terminate an employment contract with immediate effect for an urgent reason (Article 7:677(1) of the Dutch Civil Code). An urgent reason is conduct that means the employer cannot reasonably be expected to continue the employment contract (Article 7:678(1) of the Dutch Civil Code). The court looks at all the circumstances of the case: above all the nature and seriousness of the conduct, but also the length of employment, the employee’s performance and his personal circumstances.

The court found the dismissal letter clear enough; the employee could have no doubt about the reason for his dismissal. The investigation and the footage showed that he had given the company doctor a different picture of his incapacity for work than was actually the case. That was sufficient reason for summary dismissal.

The ruling does not mean that every difference between the company doctor’s assessment and behaviour outside the appointment amounts to an urgent reason. The outcome rested on the combination of the company doctor’s findings, the observation and the footage.

Was the dismissal given in time?

The employee argued that the employer had waited too long. The court disagreed. What counts is when the person authorised to dismiss learns of the urgent reason.

In May, the employer only had signals and a suspicion. It first spoke with the employee and then brought in the investigation service, because it did not want to act rashly. The court found that appropriate and careful. After the observation on 29 June, the meeting and the dismissal followed on 2 July. The employer had therefore acted promptly. The ruling does not set a fixed time limit; it always depends on the facts of the case.

Did personal circumstances play a role?

They did, but they were not decisive. A summary dismissal has serious consequences, especially after more than eleven years of service. Given how blameworthy the conduct was, the court held that this fell within the employee’s own risk. The court also rejected the claims for a transition payment, a fair compensation and compensation for irregular termination.

How does this compare with earlier case law?

A justified summary dismissal does not automatically mean that the transition payment (transitievergoeding) is lost. It is lost if the employee acted or failed to act in a seriously culpable manner (Article 7:673(7)(c) of the Dutch Civil Code). The court may still award it if refusing it would be unacceptable by standards of reasonableness and fairness (Article 7:673(8)).

That happened in January 2026 in another Amsterdam case (ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2026:95). A sick employee had told his employer he was too limited to receive a home visit, while according to an investigation agency he was driving and walking without difficulty in the same period. There too, the summary dismissal stood. Even so, the employee received a transition payment of just over EUR 12,000, because he was still fully unfit for work, was the main breadwinner and had worked for seven years without incident.

In the case of 13 November 2026, the court saw no reason to do so, despite more than eleven years of service. Whether Article 7:673(8) applies therefore depends heavily on the circumstances of the case.

What happened to the investigation costs?

The employer had deducted the investigation costs from the employee’s salary. The court accepted that such costs had probably been incurred, but the employer had not backed them up with documents. The employer must therefore repay the deducted amount within fourteen days. Each party bears its own legal costs. An appeal is still possible.

What does this mean for employers?

  • Take signals seriously, but do not act on suspicion alone. Speak with the employee first.
  • Have any investigation carried out by a licensed investigation agency and observe the privacy rules. An observation must be proportionate to the suspicion.
  • Put the findings to the employee and give him a short opportunity to respond. If no plausible explanation follows, that strengthens your position.
  • Act immediately once the urgent reason is established, and state the reason specifically in the dismissal letter.
  • If you want to recover investigation costs from the employee, support them with invoices. Setting off costs against salary is also restricted by law (Article 7:632 of the Dutch Civil Code).

What does this mean for employees?

  • Give the company doctor an accurate picture of your limitations. Being genuinely ill does not protect you if you present your limitations as worse than they are.
  • If you want to challenge a summary dismissal, you must ask the subdistrict court to annul it within two months (Article 7:686a(4) of the Dutch Civil Code).
  • After a justified summary dismissal, you risk the UWV refusing unemployment benefits.

How can we help with a summary dismissal?

  • We assess whether the reason can justify the dismissal and whether it was given in time.
  • We advise employers on a careful investigation when there are doubts about incapacity for work.
  • We file a request for annulment on time for employees, or defend employers in those proceedings.
  • We review deducted costs and salary claims.

Email us your question at info@lawandmore.nl.

Michelle Marjanovic
Michelle Marjanovic is an attorney-at-law at Law & More in Eindhoven and Amsterdam. She works mainly in immigration law and employment law, combining accurate legal work with a personal approach.

An employment issue?

Email us a few lines about your question at info@lawandmore.nl. We will let you know whether we can help and what the next step is. We do not assess cases or documents by email without an engagement.

Would you like a employment lawyer to assess your situation? In a paid consultation of EUR 300 including VAT, you receive a directional answer to your question.

This article provides general information and is not a substitute for advice on your specific situation.

Need Legal Advice?

Email us a few lines about your question at info@lawandmore.nl. We will let you know whether we can help and what the next step is. We do not assess cases or documents by email without an engagement.

Would you like a employment lawyer to assess your situation? In a paid consultation of EUR 300 including VAT, you receive a directional answer to your question.

Related articles

When an employee in the Netherlands reports sick, the employer may manage the absence but

An employer may only stop the wages of a sick employee if the employee fails

During a valid probationary period (proeftijd), your employer may end your employment contract with immediate

Learn how to handle workplace harassment with this guide. Get clear steps on documenting, reporting,

A settlement agreement (vaststellingsovereenkomst) is a written contract in which you and your employer end

An employer in the Netherlands cannot simply end a permanent employment contract. It needs one